top of page

למען הסר ספק הפוסטים בבלוג מייצגים את עמדות כותביהם ואין בהם לשקף את עמדת מרכז אריסון ל־ESG.

To avoid any doubt, the blog posts represent the positions of their authors and do not reflect the position of the Arison ESG Center.

ESG Investing and the Duty of Loyalty: What Can We Learn from the American Airlines Ruling?

In this post, I examine Spence v. American Airlines, a January 2025 decision of a federal court in Texas, and argue that the court erred in holding that investment decisions motivated in part by concern about climate change are, in themselves, a breach of the fiduciary duty of loyalty. The plaintiff, an American Airlines pilot, sued under ERISA. He claimed that the airline failed to monitor BlackRock, the main manager of the employees’ retirement plans, which used its shareholder votes to promote ESG goals.


The court found no breach of the duty of prudence, as the plans charged low fees and performed in line with the market. It held, however, that the airline breached its duty of loyalty, pointing to its own climate goals and its business ties with BlackRock. The court classified a consideration as ESG whenever it is motivated, even in part, by a social goal. In the court’s view, the duty of loyalty requires the exclusive pursuit of beneficiaries’ financial interests. ESG considerations are permitted only if their financial benefit is concrete and clear – a standard that even much of the empirical research on board diversity may not meet. In September 2025, although no financial loss was proven, the court issued a permanent injunction barring ESG-motivated proxy voting. It later awarded about $4.6 million in attorneys’ fees, explicitly to encourage compliance.


This interpretation is flawed. The court relied on Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer, a Supreme Court case concerning the duty of prudence, not loyalty. Moreover, ERISA case law contains no clear holding that loyalty is limited to financial benefit. The duty of loyalty ensures that beneficiaries’ interests, rather than the fiduciary’s own, guide decisions. Where savers’ preferences are unknown, the starting point should be that savers, especially younger ones, are not indifferent to their money supporting polluting companies that may harm their quality of life in retirement. The court thus failed to distinguish between a conflict of interest and an ethically motivated decision that may serve beneficiaries. The ruling may chill institutional investors’ willingness to consider climate risks, even when they are financially justified. In Israel, the issue has not yet reached the courts, and the Capital Market, Insurance and Savings Authority has taken a more favorable view of ESG considerations. One may hope that Israeli courts will reach a different conclusion.


To read the full post, visit our blog in Hebrew.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page